Monday's Diggings

A Fair View School Mystery


Have you ever come across an item in your family's collection and wondered why someone saved it? That's the question I'm asking about a small school booklet that belonged to my grandmother.

Among the family papers I've inherited is a booklet for Fair View School, District No. 42, Everett Township, Woodson County, Kansas, for the 1918–1919 school year.

At first glance, I thought this booklet might provide another clue about my family's history in Woodson County. After all, my Mentzer, Ricketts, Wells, and Briles families lived in that area.

However, when I looked through the list of pupils and school officers, I didn't recognize a single individual!

Well, that's not entirely true. I recognized one surname — Dooley — but not because of my Woodson County ancestors.

Fair View School, 1918–1919

The booklet identifies Fannie McCormick as the teacher and includes a photograph of a young woman, presumably Miss McCormick.

It also lists sixteen pupils attending the school.

Pupils

  • Monroe Dooley

  • Leanore Dooley

  • Leona Dooley

  • Naomi Dooley

  • Theodore Sutherland

  • Mary Sutherland

  • Etta Sutherland

  • Mildred Nantz

  • Bessie Allen

  • Ernest Colglazier

  • Richard Adams

  • Lucile Adams

  • Frances Shaffer

  • Sevilla Tichenor

  • Helen Park

  • Gladys Park

School Officers

  • H. A. Sutherland — Clerk

  • Ira Cade — Director

  • L. G. Nantz — Treasurer

  • Elizabeth Spencer — County Superintendent

The booklet also contains two poems, Sweet Remembrances and Duty. Both reflect themes of memory, character, and responsibility.

A Familiar Surname — But the Wrong Family?

The one surname that caught my attention was Dooley.

Anyone who has followed my Crawford research knows that the Dooley family is part of my Crawford FAN Club — the Friends, Associates, and Neighbors whose records might help me solve my Crawford brick wall.

I've encountered the Dooley surname while researching land transactions and neighboring families associated with my Crawfords in Kentucky and Ohio.

However, my Crawford ancestors did not live in Woodson County, Kansas.

Thus, while the Dooley surname immediately caught my eye, I have no evidence connecting the four Dooley pupils in this booklet to the families involved in my Crawford research.

Could there be a connection? Possibly. But a shared surname certainly isn't enough to establish one.

Where Are My Woodson County Families?

Since my Mentzer, Ricketts, Wells, and Briles families lived in the Woodson County area, I would have expected to recognize at least one of the surnames in the booklet.

Unfortunately, that wasn't the case.

I checked my RootsMagic database and discovered that none of the individuals listed in the booklet are currently in my family tree.

That doesn't necessarily mean they weren't connected to my family. They might have been neighbors, friends, classmates, or members of families connected through marriage.

Or perhaps the booklet had nothing to do with my family at all!

Why Did Grandma Save It?

That's the real mystery.

My grandmother kept this little booklet, and somehow it survived among the family papers until it reached me.

Was she acquainted with the teacher, Fannie McCormick? Did she know one of the pupils? Was the booklet given to her by a friend or relative? Or did it simply become part of a collection of papers she saved over the years?

I don't know.

Without additional evidence, I can't even be certain how the booklet came into her possession.

And that's one of the frustrations of working with inherited family papers. We may have the document, but the story explaining why it mattered to the person who saved it has been lost.

A Little Piece of Woodson County History

Even though I haven't identified a connection to my family, the booklet still has historical and genealogical value.

It preserves the names of sixteen children attending a rural Kansas school during the 1918–1919 school year. It identifies their teacher, the school officers, and the county superintendent.

For someone researching one of these families, this little booklet could be a wonderful discovery.

It might provide evidence of a child's presence in Everett Township, help identify possible siblings or neighbors, or add a personal detail to a family history.

And perhaps someone researching Fair View School or one of these families will recognize a name and help solve my mystery.

Another Unanswered Question

For now, I'm adding this booklet to my collection of family memorabilia, even though I haven't discovered why my grandmother kept it.

I could research each of the pupils and their families, looking for connections to my Mentzer, Ricketts, Wells, or Briles ancestors. But would that answer my question? Perhaps — or perhaps it would lead me down another genealogical rabbit hole.

For now, I'll preserve the information and share it here in the hope that it might help another researcher.

Do you have old school booklets, programs, or other memorabilia among your family papers that don't seem to have any connection to your ancestors?

And if you recognize any of the names associated with Fair View School in Woodson County, Kansas, I'd love to hear from you!

Sometimes the most interesting family history mysteries aren't about finding an ancestor. They're about discovering why a particular piece of history was saved in the first place.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Genealogy without a Subscription

Why I Upgraded to RootsMagic 12

Ancestry / RootsMagic - Tree not Searchable