Following a Crawford Trail

What Three Newspaper Articles Reveal


One of the challenges of Crawford research is determining how the various Crawford families are connected—or whether they are connected at all!

Recently, I was asked to help verify a Crawford family line that may trace back to George and Elizabeth (Poage) Crawford of Augusta County, Virginia. As a first step in that investigation, I began researching Eli Wagner Crawford (1849–1927), who was born in Madison County, Kentucky, and died in Jacksonville, Illinois.

My research led me to three newspaper articles about Eli's death. While two contained nearly identical information, the third provided an additional clue worth investigating.

Two Obituaries, One Story

Eli's obituary appeared in two newspapers:

  • Jacksonville Journal-Courier, 5 July 1927, page 8, "Eli W. Crawford Is Taken by Death."

  • The State Journal-Register, 6 July 1927, page 9, "Eli W. Crawford."

Both articles report that Eli was born on 21 November 1849 in Madison County, Kentucky. In 1868, he moved to Morgan County, Illinois, where he initially farmed before moving to Jacksonville and working as a carpenter.

In 1878, he became the owner of a small planing mill that eventually developed into the Central Planing Mill Company. He retired in December 1923.

The obituaries also provide valuable family information. Eli married Henrietta Lindsay on 25 December 1872. Their children were Thomas D., Ella Mae, Walter A., Lee R., Clara L., and Jesse, who died before his father.

Two surviving siblings were identified:

  • Thomas B. Crawford of Slater, Missouri

  • Martha Martin of Lexington, Kentucky

Although published in different newspapers, the two obituaries contain almost identical wording and information. They likely originated from the same account rather than representing two independent sources confirming the family relationships.

A Funeral Notice Provides Another Clue

A third article appeared in the Jacksonville Journal-Courier on 8 July 1927.

Titled "Crawford Rites Are Largely Attended," this article describes Eli's funeral, held on 7 July at First Baptist Church in Jacksonville. He was buried in Diamond Grove Cemetery, with the Knights Templar conducting graveside services.

The article also identifies relatives who traveled to Jacksonville for the funeral:

  • Thomas B. Crawford of Slater, Missouri

  • Thomas D. Crawford of Mobile, Alabama

  • Martha Martin of Lexington, Kentucky

  • Mrs. Sarah Hundley of Lexington, Kentucky

The first three individuals were identified in the obituaries as Eli's brother, son, and sister.

But who was Sarah Hundley?

Neither obituary mentioned her. The funeral article identifies her as a relative but does not explain the relationship.

That makes Sarah Hundley another potential clue in tracing this Crawford family.

Following the Crawford Trail Backward

My goal in this research isn't simply to document Eli Wagner Crawford's life. It is to determine whether his family can be reliably connected to George and Elizabeth (Poage) Crawford of Augusta County, Virginia.

The obituaries establish an important starting point: Madison County, Kentucky, in 1849.

They also identify two siblings whose records may help establish the identity of Eli's parents and earlier generations.

The funeral notice adds another possible connection through Sarah Hundley.

Of course, none of these articles establishes a connection to the Augusta County Crawford family. That relationship will require additional research and supporting documentation.

The Value of Multiple Newspaper Accounts

This research illustrates why I don't stop after finding a single obituary.

Two of the articles provided essentially the same biographical information. The third, published after the funeral, added details about family members who attended.

While the obituaries provide a starting point for researching Eli's parents and siblings, the funeral notice introduces another possible avenue of investigation.

Will this Crawford line eventually connect to George and Elizabeth (Poage) Crawford?

I don't know yet. But identifying Eli's Kentucky family and following the records backward is the first step toward finding out.

And that is what makes genealogy research interesting—each record may answer one question while raising several more!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Genealogy without a Subscription

Why I Upgraded to RootsMagic 12

Ancestry / RootsMagic - Tree not Searchable