When an Obituary Gets the Name Wrong

George W. Crawford


How much can we trust an obituary? As genealogists, we often turn to obituaries for information about an ancestor's birth, death, family members, and community connections. But what happens when the newspaper gets something as basic as the deceased person's name wrong?

That is exactly the situation I encountered while researching George Washington Crawford of Lexington, Kentucky.

An Obituary for J. W. Crawford

On April 18, 1906, the Lexington Herald-Leader published an obituary for a man identified as J. W. Crawford.

According to the article, Mr. Crawford was born on February 8, 1823, and died at his residence at 217 West Fourth Street in Lexington at 7:50 Wednesday morning. He was 83 years old.

The obituary also reported that he was survived by his wife, five sons, and two daughters.

His children were identified as:

  • T. B. Crawford of Slater, Missouri

  • E. W. Crawford of Jacksonville, Illinois

  • T. G. Crawford of Lexington, Kentucky

  • S. S. Crawford of Lexington, Kentucky

  • J. H. Crawford of Morehead, Kentucky

  • Mrs. J. B. Martin of Lexington, Kentucky

  • Mrs. Sarah Hundley of Louisville, Kentucky

The article noted that all of his children except the two living in the West were at his bedside when he died. Those who had been absent were on their way to Lexington.

It also described him as a devout Christian who had belonged to the Upper Street Baptist Church practically since its founding.

While this obituary provides valuable genealogical information, there is one significant problem.

Who was J. W. Crawford?

Funeral Notices Identify George W. Crawford

Additional newspaper articles published in the days surrounding the funeral identify the deceased as George W. Crawford rather than J. W. Crawford.

One funeral announcement reported that services for George W. Crawford would be held at his residence, 217 West Fourth Street, on Saturday morning at 10 o'clock.

The Rev. W. P. Hines was to officiate.

The notice also identified the honorary pallbearers as W. D. Bryant, J. R. Howard, George Cook, and H. A. White.

A more detailed funeral account published April 21, 1906, carried the headline:

"MR. CRAWFORD LAID TO REST WITH IMPRESSIVE CEREMONIES."

This article identified the deceased as George W. Crawford, aged 84, and reported that he had died Wednesday morning at 7:50.

The funeral was held at his residence at 217 West Fourth Street, with the Rev. W. P. Hines officiating.

The active pallbearers were members of the family, while the honorary pallbearers were:

  • W. D. Bryant

  • J. R. Howard

  • J. W. Appleton

  • George H. Cook

  • H. A. White

The article also described the services at the grave, which were conducted by the Masons. George Crawford had been a devoted member of that organization for many years.

Music at the residence was provided by the Upper Street church choir, and the newspaper described the floral offerings as numerous and beautiful.

Another funeral account, published in the Lexington Herald on April 22, repeated much of this information. It also identified the deceased as George W. Crawford.

Thus, while the obituary identifies the deceased as J. W. Crawford, the funeral notices consistently identify him as George W. Crawford.

The matching address, time of death, funeral arrangements, and other details strongly suggest that these articles describe the same man.

What About the Children?

The strongest evidence supporting this identification comes from the family.

My RootsMagic database contains a family for George Washington Crawford, born February 8, 1823.

According to the descendant report, George married twice.

His first wife was Martha Bolton, who died September 7, 1852.

Their children were:

  • Thomas Bolton Crawford (1848–1928) — The T. B. Crawford identified in the obituary as living in Slater, Missouri.

  • Eli Wagner Crawford (1849–1927) — The E. W. Crawford living in Jacksonville, Illinois.

  • James M. Crawford (1851–1903) — Died before his father and therefore was not included among the surviving children.

  • Martha Crawford (1852–1936) — Married James Benjamin Martin and was identified in the obituary as Mrs. J. B. Martin of Lexington.

George's second wife was Elizabeth Hacker (1832–1916).

Their children were:

  • Silas S. Crawford (1854–1938) — The S. S. Crawford living in Lexington.

  • Theophilus Garrett Crawford (1855–1944) — The T. G. Crawford living in Lexington.

  • Julius Hacker Crawford (1857–1932) — The J. H. Crawford identified as living in Morehead, Kentucky.

  • Sarah Frances Crawford (1859–1938) — Married Richard Z. Hunley and appears to be the daughter identified as Mrs. Sarah Hundley of Louisville.

The descendant report identifies eight children, including James M. Crawford, who died in 1903.

That leaves exactly seven surviving children: five sons and two daughters.

Those seven children correspond to the seven children identified in the obituary for J. W. Crawford!

This is much stronger evidence than simply finding two newspaper articles with the same address and death information.

The children's names, initials, and family relationships provide additional support for identifying the man in the obituary as George Washington Crawford.

There is another small discrepancy worth noting. The obituary identifies Sarah's married surname as Hundley, while my RootsMagic report identifies her husband as Richard Z. Hunley. This difference is another reminder to compare newspaper information with other records.

An Age Discrepancy

The incorrect name is not the only discrepancy among these newspaper articles.

The obituary reports that J. W. Crawford was 83 years old.

The funeral notices identify George W. Crawford as 84 years old.

Since the obituary gives his birth date as February 8, 1823, he would have been 83 years old when he died in April 1906.

Thus, the age reported in the obituary appears to be correct.

This relatively minor discrepancy illustrates another reason to compare multiple sources. Even when newspapers are reporting on the same individual and the same event, they may not agree on every detail.

Why Compare Multiple Newspaper Articles?

Had I located only the obituary for J. W. Crawford, I might have questioned whether it belonged to the George Washington Crawford family.

After all, the name is different.

However, the funeral notices provide additional evidence identifying the deceased as George W. Crawford.

More importantly, the names of the surviving children correspond to the family identified in my RootsMagic database.

I have also been locating and transcribing obituaries for George's children. Those obituaries, along with census records and other sources, provide additional evidence supporting the relationships identified in the descendant report.

This is an excellent example of why genealogists should avoid relying on a single source.

An obituary may contain a typographical error, an incorrect age, or inaccurate information about family members. By comparing multiple records, we can identify those discrepancies and begin evaluating which information is most reliable.

In this case, the newspaper apparently got the deceased man's initials wrong, but it provided an excellent list of his surviving children.

That list became the key to confirming his identity.

Another Crawford Family to Investigate

My interest in this family is part of a larger research project.

I have been asked to help verify a Crawford family line that may connect to George and Elizabeth (Poage) Crawford of Augusta County, Virginia.

My research began with Eli Wagner Crawford of Jacksonville, Illinois, one of the sons identified in this obituary.

As I began locating records for Eli and his siblings, I worked backward to their father, George Washington Crawford.

The obituary and funeral notices provide valuable evidence about George's family, but they do not establish his parentage or prove a connection to the Augusta County Crawfords.

That remains a question for further research.

For now, these newspaper articles have helped clarify the identity of George Washington Crawford, identify his surviving children, and demonstrate how several newspaper accounts can work together to resolve an apparent contradiction.

And they provide a useful reminder:

Sometimes the most valuable information in an obituary isn't the name at the top. It's the family members listed below it.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Genealogy without a Subscription

Why I Upgraded to RootsMagic 12

Ancestry / RootsMagic - Tree not Searchable