Saturday Night Genealogy Fun
Thanksgiving with the Crawfords in 1926
Calling all Genea-Musings fans!
It's Saturday Night again — time for some more Genealogy Fun!
This week's challenge from Randy Seaver at Genea-Musings asks us to imagine how our ancestors might have celebrated Thanksgiving 100 years ago. Where were they living? Who might have gathered around the table? What foods would they have enjoyed? And what might they have been thankful for?
We are even encouraged to use artificial intelligence to help create a historical fiction story based on what we know about our ancestors.
For this challenge, I'm traveling back to Dodge City, Kansas, in November 1926, to spend Thanksgiving with my great-grandparents, Judson and Josie Crawford, and their extended family.
The Crawford Family in 1926
In 1926, my great-grandparents, Judson and Josie Crawford, were living at 504 Avenue G in Dodge City, Kansas.
Three of their children were still living at home:
Hugh Crawford, age 24
Esther Crawford, age 21
Lois Crawford, age 17
Judson's mother, Mary Crawford, lived at 911 Second, with her youngest son, Nelson G. Crawford, and his wife, Cora, living next door.
Several of Judson and Josie's married children also lived nearby.
Their son Leon and his wife, Winnie, lived in Dodge City at 510 Avenue G. Both Judson and Leon worked for the Santa Fe Railroad.
Their daughter Helen and her husband, Russell Horton, lived at 107 Poplar Street with their three young children:
Russell Horton, age 6
Marjorie Horton, age 3
Elaine Horton, just 6 months old
Russell Horton also worked for the railroad.
Living about an hour away in Cimarron, Kansas was Judd and Josie's oldest daughter, Bernice, with her husband, George Allen. Their household included four children:
George Allen, age 12
Charmaine Allen, age 9
Bernice Allen, age 4
Theda Ruth Allen, age 2
Thus, there were four generations of the Crawford family living in southwestern Kansas in 1926.
But would they all have gathered for Thanksgiving?
A Railroad Family's Thanksgiving
Thanksgiving fell on Thursday, November 25, 1926.
For families whose livelihoods depended on the railroad, Thanksgiving wasn't necessarily a day off.
Judson Crawford, his son Leon, and his son-in-law Russell Horton all worked for the railroad. Trains continued running on holidays, and railroad employees couldn't simply close up shop for Thanksgiving.
It seems unlikely that all three men would have had the holiday off.
Perhaps the family celebrated in smaller groups on Thanksgiving Day. Or perhaps they waited until the following Sunday, November 28, when more family members might have been available.
Of course, even Sunday wasn't necessarily a day off for railroad workers.
For my imaginary Thanksgiving celebration, I'm choosing Sunday, November 28, and imagining that the family was fortunate enough to arrange their schedules so they could gather.
Thanksgiving Dinner at 504 Avenue G
The following story is historical fiction based on known family relationships, residences, occupations, and food traditions. The conversations and details of the gathering are imagined.
It was a chilly Sunday morning in Dodge City, Kansas.
Inside the Crawford home at 504 Avenue G, Josie was busy preparing a Thanksgiving dinner. Although the holiday had officially passed three days earlier, today was the day the family would celebrate together.
Esther and Lois were helping their mother in the kitchen. Hugh had been given the job of making sure there were enough chairs for everyone.
The turkey was roasting, filling the house with a wonderful aroma. Potatoes were ready to be mashed, and dressing would soon be warming in the oven.
There would be plenty of gravy, of course.
And there were scalloped oysters — a dish that would remain part of the family's holiday traditions for generations.
Perhaps Josie also prepared fried sweet potatoes, squash, and green beans. Pumpkin pies waited for dessert.
Before long, the first guests began arriving.
Leon and Winnie didn't have far to travel. Leon had managed to arrange his railroad schedule so he could join the family.
Helen and Russell Horton arrived with their three children. Six-year-old Russell was excited to see his cousins, while three-year-old Marjorie was eager to explore Grandma Crawford's house.
Baby Elaine, only six months old, was undoubtedly passed from one loving relative to another.
The arrival of Bernice and George Allen from Cimarron brought even more excitement. Their four children joined the growing group of cousins.
Twelve-year-old George and nine-year-old Charmaine were old enough to help entertain the younger children, while little Bernice and Theda Ruth added to the commotion.
Judson's mother, Mary Crawford, joined the gathering, perhaps accompanied by Nelson and Cora from next door.
At the age of 77, Mary had witnessed enormous changes during her lifetime.
Born before the Civil War, she had lived through the settlement of the American West, the arrival of the railroads, and the transformation of Dodge City from a frontier cattle town into an established Kansas community.
Now she was surrounded by children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren.
What a remarkable sight that must have been!
Around the Thanksgiving Table
With so many people gathered, finding enough room for everyone would have been a challenge.
Perhaps the adults sat around the dining room table while the younger children ate at a separate table.
Judson may have offered a prayer of thanksgiving before everyone began passing the food.
The conversation undoubtedly included news of the railroad.
With three railroad men in the family, there would have been plenty to discuss about trains, schedules, and working conditions.
The children might have talked about school, their friends, and the approaching Christmas holiday.
Mary might have shared memories of earlier Thanksgivings, when life was very different.
Perhaps someone asked her about Thanksgiving celebrations during her younger years.
Did she remember the years when the family had far less? Did she marvel at the conveniences available in 1926?
And what about the women gathered around the table?
Josie, Bernice, Helen, Esther, Lois, Winnie, and Cora might have exchanged recipes, family news, and stories about the children.
After dinner, the men might have gathered to visit while the women cleaned up the kitchen — a division of labor that was common in many households of the era.
Meanwhile, the children probably found ways to entertain themselves.
By late afternoon, the visitors would begin gathering their coats and preparing to return home.
The Allens faced the trip back to Cimarron, while the Dodge City families had much shorter journeys.
And Josie could finally sit down and enjoy a moment of quiet after feeding her large family.
What Might They Have Been Thankful For?
The year 1926 fell between two major events in American history: World War I and the Great Depression.
The Crawfords could not have known that the stock market would crash just three years later, ushering in a decade of economic hardship.
For the moment, however, they had much for which to be thankful.
They had family nearby. Several generations were living within a relatively small geographic area.
The railroad provided employment for Judson, Leon, and Russell.
There were young children bringing joy to the family, including baby Elaine, born earlier that year.
And Mary Crawford had the opportunity to see her family grow into another generation.
Perhaps their greatest blessing was simply being together.
Separating Family History from Imagination
While I enjoyed imagining this Thanksgiving gathering, I recognize that much of the story is speculation.
I know where these Crawford family members were living in 1926. I know their family relationships and the ages of the children. I also know that Judson, Leon, and Russell worked for the railroad.
What I don't know is whether they gathered for Thanksgiving that year.
I don't know who hosted the celebration, whether the railroad employees had time off, or whether the family celebrated on Thursday or Sunday.
I also don't have a menu from 1926.
However, I do have memories of Crawford family holiday meals from the 1950s. Those meals included turkey, dressing, mashed potatoes, gravy, scalloped oysters, and pumpkin pie. Sometimes there were fried sweet potatoes, squash, and green beans.
Could those traditions have been passed down from Josie's kitchen?
I certainly like to think so.
And that is one of the pleasures of family history. While documents tell us where our ancestors lived and what they did, imagining their everyday lives helps us see them as people rather than simply names and dates.
A Thanksgiving Wish
If I could travel back to November 1926, I would love to visit that house at 504 Avenue G.
I'd like to watch Josie prepare dinner, listen to the railroad stories, and hear Mary Crawford talk about her life.
I'd especially enjoy seeing the children together, knowing how their lives would unfold in the decades ahead.
And, of course, I'd SKIP those scalloped oysters!
What about your ancestors? Do you know where they were living at Thanksgiving 100 years ago? Have you ever tried imagining a holiday celebration based on the family history you've uncovered?
Perhaps this week's Saturday Night Genealogy Fun challenge will inspire you to do just that.

Comments
Post a Comment